What is an exhausted ballot?
A ballot becomes exhausted (some places say "inactive") when every candidate it ranks has been eliminated. It counted in earlier rounds; it simply has no one left to count for. It is then left out of the total used to measure a majority.
Ballots exhaust for two main reasons: the voter chose to rank only some candidates, or the ballot limited how many rankings were allowed. A ballot that ranks no one at all is a blank (an "undervote") and never counted in the first place.
An example
| Voters | 1st choice | 2nd choice |
|---|---|---|
| 38 | Ortiz | — |
| 31 | Price | Quinn |
| 18 | Quinn | — |
| 9 | Ross | Price |
| 4 | Ross | — |
| 100 | ballots in total | |
| Candidate | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ortiz | 38 38.0% | 38 39.6% | 38 48.7% |
| PriceWinner | 31 31.0% | 40 41.7% | 40 51.3% |
| Quinn | 18 18.0% | 18 18.8% | out |
| Ross | 13 13.0% | out | out |
| Exhausted (no longer counting) | 0 | 4 | 22 |
| Ballots still counting | 100 | 96 | 78 |
- Round 1. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Ortiz leads with 38, short of a majority. Ross has the fewest votes and is eliminated. Those ballots move to their next choice: 9 to Price. 4 ballots rank no one else still in the race and are exhausted.
- Round 2. 96 ballots are counting, so a majority is 49. Price leads with 40, short of a majority. Quinn has the fewest votes and is eliminated. 18 ballots rank no one else still in the race and are exhausted.
- Round 3. 78 ballots are counting, so a majority is 40. Price has 40 (51.3%) and wins.
The winner has a majority of the ballots still counting in the final round (40 of 78) but not of all ballots cast (40 of 100).
How often it happens in real elections
| Election | Rounds | Exhausted | Share of first-round ballots |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maine's 2nd Congressional District, 2018 | 2 | 8,253 | 2.8% |
| Alaska's U.S. House special election, August 2022 | 2 | 11,243 | 6.0% |
| New York City Democratic mayoral primary, 2021 | 8 | 140,202 | 14.9% |
| San Francisco mayoral election, 2024 | 14 | 57,859 | 14.8% |
A peer-reviewed study of more than 600,000 ballots in four local elections (Oakland 2010, Pierce County 2008, San Francisco 2011 and San Leandro 2010) found exhaustion rates from 9.6% to 27.1%, and that in all four the winner received less than a majority of all votes cast. Most exhausted ballots came from voters who ranked only one or two candidates (Burnett & Kogan, Electoral Studies, 2015).
How to read this
Critics see exhausted ballots as voters who were left out of the final decision. Supporters note that the comparable alternative, a separate runoff election, also loses voters: anyone who doesn't come back for round two. Both points are made in pros and cons.
Ranking limits
Some places cap how many candidates you can rank. New York City allows up to five; San Francisco allowed three until it expanded to ten for 2024. With 13 candidates in the 2021 NYC primary, a ballot could exhaust even if the voter used every ranking allowed. Alaska and Maine let voters rank every candidate on the ballot.
Overvotes, skips and duplicates
- Overvote (two candidates given the same rank): most U.S. rules stop counting the ballot when that ranking is reached, because the voter's preference is ambiguous. The rankings before it still count.
- Skipped ranking (a 1st and a 3rd, no 2nd): many places just move to the next marked ranking; some stop after two skips in a row (Maine's rule).
- Duplicate (the same candidate ranked more than once): the later marks are ignored.
Exact rules vary by state and city; the local election office publishes them. Research on New York City found more ranking errors in lower-income, less-educated areas in 2021, and that error rates fell substantially by 2025 (Cormack, Stevens Institute of Technology).
How ties are broken
A tie matters in two places: for last place (who is eliminated) and in the final round (who wins). Common rules, in order:
- Look back. Compare the tied candidates' totals in the previous round, then the one before, and eliminate whoever was lower.
- Draw lots. If they were tied all the way back, the decision is made by lot (a coin toss, cards or a random draw, depending on local law).
Here is a tie for last place resolved by looking back:
| Voters | 1st choice | 2nd choice |
|---|---|---|
| 40 | Avery | Casey |
| 26 | Blake | Drew |
| 22 | Casey | Blake |
| 8 | Drew | Casey |
| 4 | Drew | Blake |
| 100 | ballots in total | |
| Candidate | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Avery | 40 40.0% | 40 40.0% | 40 43.5% |
| BlakeWinner | 26 26.0% | 30 30.0% | 52 56.5% |
| Casey | 22 22.0% | 30 30.0% | out |
| Drew | 12 12.0% | out | out |
| Exhausted (no longer counting) | 0 | 0 | 8 |
| Ballots still counting | 100 | 100 | 92 |
- Round 1. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Avery leads with 40, short of a majority. Drew has the fewest votes and is eliminated. Those ballots move to their next choice: 4 to Blake, 8 to Casey.
- Round 2. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Avery leads with 40, short of a majority. Tie for last between Blake and Casey, broken by earlier-round totals. Casey has the fewest votes and is eliminated. Those ballots move to their next choice: 22 to Blake. 8 ballots rank no one else still in the race and are exhausted.
- Round 3. 92 ballots are counting, so a majority is 47. Blake has 52 (56.5%) and wins.
Exact ties are rare in large elections but do happen in small ones. Our counter uses the same two steps and tells you when a tie was broken by lot.