A history of ranked-choice voting

Ranked ballots are older than most people assume. The ideas come from 18th-century France, the counting methods from 19th-century Denmark, Britain and the United States, and the longest-running national use from Australia.

Last reviewed · Nonpartisan explainer · Sources linked inline

Voting theory in the 1700s

In 1780s France, two members of the Academy of Sciences argued about how a group should choose among several options. Jean-Charles de Borda proposed scoring candidates by their position on each ballot (the Borda count). The Marquis de Condorcet proposed comparing every pair of candidates head to head, and in 1785 described the "paradox" that a group's preferences can go in a circle even when every individual's are consistent (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). Neither proposed instant runoff, but both established that how you count ranked ballots changes who wins.

Andræ, Hare, Mill and Ware

  • Carl Andræ, a Danish mathematician and politician, devised a transferable-vote method that Denmark used from 1855. (Mostly documented in secondary sources.)
  • Thomas Hare, an English lawyer, published his scheme in 1857 and a fuller treatise in 1859, apparently without knowing Andræ's work. His multi-winner method is why STV is often called the "Hare system" (Britannica).
  • John Stuart Mill championed Hare's plan in Considerations on Representative Government (1861), praising its "almost unparalleled merit" (Mill, ch. 7).
  • William Robert Ware, an architecture professor at MIT, is credited with adapting Hare's method to elect a single winner around 1870. That single-winner version is what Americans now call ranked-choice or instant-runoff voting. (The attribution comes mainly from secondary and advocacy sources.)

Australia: the longest-running national use

  • 1892: Queensland adopted a "contingent vote," in which only the top two candidates went to a second count (Queensland Parliament).
  • 1918: after a by-election in Swan where a split conservative vote let Labor win with about a third of the votes, the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 introduced preferential voting for the federal House of Representatives (Australian Electoral Commission). Its first use, the Corangamite by-election that December, was won by a candidate who trailed on first preferences.
  • 1924: voting became compulsory federally.
  • 1949: the Senate began using the multi-winner single transferable vote.
  • Today: House voters must number every candidate, and a winner needs more than 50% of formal votes after preferences (AEC).

Ireland, Malta and the United Kingdom

  • Malta has used STV for its parliament since 1921.
  • Ireland held its first contested national election under STV in June 1922 and wrote STV into its 1937 Constitution. Governments twice asked voters to switch to first-past-the-post; voters said no in 1959 (51.8%) and 1968 (60.8%) (Government of Ireland). The Irish president is elected by STV with one seat, which is instant runoff.
  • Northern Ireland uses STV for its Assembly and councils; Scotland adopted it for council elections, first used in 2007.
  • London elected its mayor with the "supplementary vote," a two-choice shortcut, from 2000 until the Elections Act 2022 replaced it with first-past-the-post (legislation.gov.uk).
  • In 2011 the UK held a national referendum on using instant runoff (the "Alternative Vote") for the House of Commons; it was rejected.

Early U.S. use, 1910s–1960s

Progressive-era reformers brought ranked ballots to American cities. Ashtabula, Ohio, used proportional STV from 1915; Cleveland, Cincinnati, Toledo, New York City (for its council, from 1937 until a 1947 repeal) and others followed. Several states also used ranked or "supplementary" ballots in primaries. Nearly all were repealed by the early 1960s; Cambridge, Massachusetts, which adopted STV in 1941, kept it and still uses it (Wikipedia overview).

The modern U.S. revival

  • 2002–2004: San Francisco voters approved Proposition A in March 2002, about 55% to 45% (Ballotpedia); first used for supervisors in 2004.
  • 2006–2011: Minneapolis adopted it in 2006 (first used 2009) and St. Paul in 2009 (first used 2011). Oakland, Berkeley and San Leandro first used it in 2010.
  • 2016–2018: Maine voters approved statewide ranked-choice voting with Question 5, 52.1% to 47.9% (results summary). After the state's high court advised it couldn't be used for state general elections under the Maine Constitution and the legislature delayed it, voters restored it by people's veto in June 2018, 53.9% to 46.1%. Its first federal general-election use decided the 2nd District race that November.
  • 2019–2021: New York City voters approved ranked-choice primaries and special elections with 73.6% in 2019 (Ballotpedia); first used in 2021.
  • 2020–2022: Alaska's Measure 2 passed with 50.55% (Ballotpedia), creating a top-four open primary with ranked-choice general elections, first used in 2022.
  • 2024: Washington, D.C., voters approved Initiative 83; ranked-choice primaries were first used in June 2026. Portland, Oregon, used ranked ballots for the first time in November 2024.

Bans and repeal campaigns

As ranked-choice voting spread, opposition organized too. Tennessee and Florida banned it in 2022, and by March 2026, 19 states had passed bans (Ballotpedia News). In November 2024, statewide measures to adopt it failed in Colorado, Idaho, Nevada and Oregon, while Missouri voters approved a constitutional ban. Alaska's repeal measure failed by 743 votes after a recount (Alaska Current), and a second repeal attempt in November 2026 was trailing in unofficial results (Alaska Beacon). Details are on where it's used and banned.

Earlier reversals are part of the story too. Burlington, Vermont, repealed ranked-choice voting in 2010 after a disputed 2009 mayoral race, then restored it for city council elections by a 64% vote in 2021 (Ballotpedia).

Timeline

  1. 1785Condorcet describes the voting paradox.
  2. 1855Denmark uses Andræ's transferable vote.
  3. 1857–59Thomas Hare publishes the single transferable vote.
  4. c. 1870W. R. Ware adapts it to elect one winner (instant runoff).
  5. 1892Queensland adopts a contingent vote.
  6. 1918Australia adopts preferential voting for its House of Representatives.
  7. 1921–22Malta and Ireland adopt STV.
  8. 1941Cambridge, Massachusetts, adopts STV; still in use.
  9. 1949Australian Senate switches to STV.
  10. 1959, 1968Irish voters reject replacing STV.
  11. 2002San Francisco approves ranked-choice voting (first used 2004).
  12. 2016–18Maine adopts it statewide; first used in 2018.
  13. 2020–22Alaska adopts it; first used in 2022.
  14. 2021New York City's first ranked-choice primaries.
  15. 2022–2619 states pass bans (as of March 2026).
  16. 2024Alaska repeal fails by 743 votes; four statewide adoption measures fail.
  17. 2026Washington, D.C., holds its first ranked-choice primary.

Current as of November 15, 2026.