Ranked-choice voting examples

Six small elections, each showing one thing that can happen in an instant-runoff count. The ballots are made up; every round is computed, not typed in. Load any of them into the counter and change the numbers to see what flips the result.

Last reviewed · Nonpartisan explainer · Sources linked inline

1. Majority in round one

If a candidate has more than half of the first choices, the count is over immediately. Later rankings are never looked at. This is common: in many ranked-choice elections the winner is clear on first choices alone.

Example 1: the ballots
Voters1st choice2nd choice
55AdamsCruz
30BakerCruz
15CruzBaker
100ballots in total
Example 1: the count, round by round
CandidateRound 1
AdamsWinner 55 55.0%
Baker 30 30.0%
Cruz 15 15.0%
Exhausted (no longer counting)0
Ballots still counting100
  1. Round 1. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Adams has 55 (55.0%) and wins.

2. The leader holds on

Most of the time the first-round leader also wins the final round. Transfers add votes to everyone, but not enough to change the order.

Example 2: the ballots
Voters1st choice2nd choice3rd choice
44LeeShah—
30MorenoKowalski—
16ShahLeeMoreno
10KowalskiMorenoLee
100ballots in total
Example 2: the count, round by round
CandidateRound 1Round 2Round 3
LeeWinner 44 44.0% 44 44.0% 60 60.0%
Moreno 30 30.0% 40 40.0% 40 40.0%
Shah 16 16.0% 16 16.0% out
Kowalski 10 10.0% outout
Exhausted (no longer counting)000
Ballots still counting100100100
  1. Round 1. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Lee leads with 44, short of a majority. Kowalski has the fewest votes and is eliminated. Those ballots move to their next choice: 10 to Moreno.
  2. Round 2. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Lee leads with 44, short of a majority. Shah has the fewest votes and is eliminated. Those ballots move to their next choice: 16 to Lee.
  3. Round 3. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Lee has 60 (60.0%) and wins.

3. A comeback from third

The case people find surprising. The leader is many voters' last choice, so as other candidates drop out, their ballots flow to the leader's rival instead.

Example 3: the ballots
Voters1st choice2nd choice3rd choice
34RiveraOkaforNguyen
8RiveraNguyen—
28NguyenOkaforRivera
18OkaforNguyenRivera
7OkaforRivera—
5PatelOkafor—
100ballots in total
Example 3: the count, round by round
CandidateRound 1Round 2Round 3
Rivera 42 42.0% 42 42.0% 42 42.0%
Nguyen 28 28.0% 28 28.0% out
OkaforWinner 25 25.0% 30 30.0% 58 58.0%
Patel 5 5.0% outout
Exhausted (no longer counting)000
Ballots still counting100100100
  1. Round 1. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Rivera leads with 42, short of a majority. Patel has the fewest votes and is eliminated. Those ballots move to their next choice: 5 to Okafor.
  2. Round 2. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Rivera leads with 42, short of a majority. Nguyen has the fewest votes and is eliminated. Those ballots move to their next choice: 28 to Okafor.
  3. Round 3. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Okafor has 58 (58.0%) and wins.

4. Vote splitting (the "spoiler" problem)

Hayes and Irwin are similar candidates. Their supporters, 60 voters together, prefer either of them to Grant. Under a plain "most votes wins" rule, Grant wins with 40 because the other 60 votes are split. Under instant runoff, Irwin is eliminated and Irwin's voters move to Hayes.

Example 4: the ballots
Voters1st choice2nd choice
40Grant—
35HayesIrwin
25IrwinHayes
100ballots in total
Example 4: the count, round by round
CandidateRound 1Round 2
Grant 40 40.0% 40 40.0%
HayesWinner 35 35.0% 60 60.0%
Irwin 25 25.0% out
Exhausted (no longer counting)00
Ballots still counting100100
  1. Round 1. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Grant leads with 40, short of a majority. Irwin has the fewest votes and is eliminated. Those ballots move to their next choice: 25 to Hayes.
  2. Round 2. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Hayes has 60 (60.0%) and wins.

Reducing this kind of vote splitting is the most common argument for ranked-choice voting. It doesn't remove every strategic problem; see the center-squeeze example.

5. Exhausted ballots

Here, many voters ranked only one candidate. When their candidate is eliminated, their ballots have nowhere to go.

Example 5: the ballots
Voters1st choice2nd choice
38Ortiz—
31PriceQuinn
18Quinn—
9RossPrice
4Ross—
100ballots in total
Example 5: the count, round by round
CandidateRound 1Round 2Round 3
Ortiz 38 38.0% 38 39.6% 38 48.7%
PriceWinner 31 31.0% 40 41.7% 40 51.3%
Quinn 18 18.0% 18 18.8% out
Ross 13 13.0% outout
Exhausted (no longer counting)0422
Ballots still counting1009678
  1. Round 1. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Ortiz leads with 38, short of a majority. Ross has the fewest votes and is eliminated. Those ballots move to their next choice: 9 to Price. 4 ballots rank no one else still in the race and are exhausted.
  2. Round 2. 96 ballots are counting, so a majority is 49. Price leads with 40, short of a majority. Quinn has the fewest votes and is eliminated. 18 ballots rank no one else still in the race and are exhausted.
  3. Round 3. 78 ballots are counting, so a majority is 40. Price has 40 (51.3%) and wins.

Price wins with 40 votes: a majority of the 78 ballots still counting, but only 40% of all 100 ballots. Whether that counts as a "majority winner" is a real debate. In a two-round runoff, voters who sit out the second election have the same effect. More on exhausted ballots.

6. A tie for last place

After Drew is eliminated, Blake and Casey are tied for last with 30 each. This example breaks the tie the way many U.S. rules do: by going back to the earlier round, where Casey had fewer votes (22 to 26). If they had been tied in every earlier round too, the tie would be decided by lot.

Example 6: the ballots
Voters1st choice2nd choice
40AveryCasey
26BlakeDrew
22CaseyBlake
8DrewCasey
4DrewBlake
100ballots in total
Example 6: the count, round by round
CandidateRound 1Round 2Round 3
Avery 40 40.0% 40 40.0% 40 43.5%
BlakeWinner 26 26.0% 30 30.0% 52 56.5%
Casey 22 22.0% 30 30.0% out
Drew 12 12.0% outout
Exhausted (no longer counting)008
Ballots still counting10010092
  1. Round 1. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Avery leads with 40, short of a majority. Drew has the fewest votes and is eliminated. Those ballots move to their next choice: 4 to Blake, 8 to Casey.
  2. Round 2. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Avery leads with 40, short of a majority. Tie for last between Blake and Casey, broken by earlier-round totals. Casey has the fewest votes and is eliminated. Those ballots move to their next choice: 22 to Blake. 8 ballots rank no one else still in the race and are exhausted.
  3. Round 3. 92 ballots are counting, so a majority is 47. Blake has 52 (56.5%) and wins.

Real-world examples

These made-up examples have real counterparts, with official numbers: